Story Poster
Photo by Pat Kinnison - Chief Photographer
Oklahoma State Football

New College Football Coach Rankings and Gundy Holds Steady

May 20, 2021
3,190

STILLWATER – On Wednesday CBS Sports released their annual ranking of Power Five college football head coaches. It is list season as spring football is over and the wait for the football season is on. This is a list I think is usually pretty fair and makes sense. It is not a one-person creation as the entire college football staff puts a ballot in and the list is the product of tallying all the ballots. I can live with that a lot more than I can one person’s opinion.

I did feel the need to throw in a couple of purely factual and results-based lists in with the CBS Sports tally. I thought the list of top 10 winningest coaches (win total) was pertinent and then I had to throw in a list of how all the coaches in the Big 12 stand. On that list for full transparency, I have the total collegiate record of each coach, their Big 12 record in parenthesis, and then their win percentage in Big 12 only next to that record.

We start with the CBS Sports rankings.

Ranking Coach School Comment
1. Nick Saban  Alabama Absolutely, no one else can have this spot
2. Dabo Swinney Clemson Terry Don Phillips can identify coaching talent
3. Lincoln Riley Oklahoma He is definitely top five this early in his career
4. Ryan Day Ohio State He’s been good since taking over
5. Brian Kelly Notre Dame Two CFP invites over the past three seasons
6. Jimbo Fisher Texas A&M Has the Aggies poised for huge season
7. Kirby Smart Georgia I'd like to see a little more
8. Pat Fitzgerald Northwestern Gets a lot of credit for winning at Northwestern
9. Matt Campbell Iowa State Has had two really strong seasons at a school not used to it
10. Dan Mullen Florida  Top 10?
11. Ed Orgeron LSU One hit wonder?
12. Mack Brown UNC Should be ranked higher, hall of famer in my book
13. James Franklin Penn State Has risen from Vanderbilt, but bad year in 2020
14. Kyle Whittingham Utah Ranks behind Gundy in record and wins
15. Mike Gundy Okla.State As consistent as any coach on college ranks
16. Mario Cristobal Oregon Still early in tenure and yet to make mark
17. Kirk Ferentz Iowa Dean of Big 10 coaches very consistent
18. Paul Chryst Wisconsin Threatened a couple of times with winning Big 10
19. Gary Patterson TCU Long run of consistency until last few years 
20. Tom Allen Indiana Amazing run since taking over Hoosiers

I really like what I’ve seen out of Tom Allen, both as a scheme and X-and-O coach and especially as a motivator and program manager. Nothing to do with the last name, I promise. 

Pat Kinnison - Chief Photographer
Mike Gunt]dy and Gary Patterson

Three ways to compare is always better than one.

The CBS rankings get a little straightening out from the winning active coaches list. I sure think overall, and based on last season that Mike Gundy should be ahead of Kyle Whittingham and James Franklin, but I can’t put Gundy ahead of Mack Brown.

Ranking Coach School W/L Record
1. Nick Saban Toledo/Mich.St./LSU/Alabama 256-65-1
2.  Mack Brown Tulane/UNC/Texas/UNC 253-127-1
3.  Gary Patterson TCU 178-74
4. Frank Solich Nebraska/Ohio 173-101
5. Kirk Ferentz Iowa 168-106
6. Mike Leach Tex.Tech/Wash.St./Miss.St. 143-97
7. Dabo Swinney Clemson 140-33
8. Mike Gundy Oklahoma State 137-67
Tied-9th Brian Kelly C.Mich./Cincinnati/ND 134-61
Tied -9th Kyle Whittingham Utah 134-66

Finally, smaller sample size of coaches, but it will always be more accurate to compare coaches in competition head-to-head. I find it is a great way to discover who can do more with more, who can do more with less, and who can do well with what they have or well with what they don’t have.

Rank Coach School Record (Record at Big 12 school) Pct. in Big 12
1. Lincoln Riley OU 45-8 (45-8) .849
2. Mike Gundy OSU 137-67 (137-67) .672
3. Gary Patterson TCU 178-74 (69-44) .611
4. Matt Campbell Iowa St. 70-43 (35-28) .555
5. Chris Klieman K-State 81-17 (12-11) .522
6. Neal Brown WVU 46-27 (11-11) .500
7. Matt Wells Tex.Tech 52-48 (8-14) .363
8. Dave Aranda Baylor 2-7 (2-7) .222
9. Lance Leipold Kansas 146-39 (0-0) .000
10. Steve Sarkisian Texas 46-35 (0-0) .000

Lincoln Riley has earned his ranking, but so has Gundy. Another conference championship and win or two over Oklahoma would make Gundy even more centented in his legacy. He is absolutely the greatest coach in Oklahoma State  

Discussion from...

New College Football Coach Rankings and Gundy Holds Steady

2,745 Views | 3 Replies | Last: 4 yr ago by CaliforniaCowboy
CaliforniaCowboy
How long do you want to ignore this user?
who the heck is Lance Leipold?

Zach Lancaster
How long do you want to ignore this user?
Kansas' new coach from Buffalo. He went 109-6 and won six DIII national titles at Wisconsin-Whitewater and was pretty successful at Buffalo.
CaliforniaCowboy
How long do you want to ignore this user?
"pretty successful", like Turner Gill?

Refresh
Page 1 of 1
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.