Drew Mestemaker Semifinalist for Davey O'Brien Award, Now Will He Play at ASU?
STILLWATER – Oklahoma State running back Caleb Hawkins found out earlier in the day that he was a semifinalist for the Doak Walker Award for the top college running back. No surprise that later Drew Mestemaker was named a semifinalist for the Davey O’Brien Award for top Division I college quarterback. Mestemaker has made their weekly “Great Eight” list at least four times this season. The Oklahoma State quarterback was on there after the wins over Oregon, West Virginia, Colorado, and Kansas State. On the season, Mestemaker has completed 233-of-351 passing for 3,239-yards with 30 touchdowns and 10 interceptions. He is completing 66.4 percent of his passes. He has run 44 times for 169-yards and three touchdowns, including his airborne effort over the Oregon defense in the 39-31 Cowboy victory.
Mestemaker is also one of three finalist for the Burlsworth Trophy, which he won a year ago as the top walkon of former walkon player in college football.
He is a deserving candidate for both awards, but the question this week is, will he play at Arizona State on Saturday?
Mestemaker was banged around pretty good by the Texas Tech pass rush including a stinger on a dropped snap and recovery on the first offensive series. Mestemaker passed it off as not that significant after the game.
“I just landed on my shoulder weird, and it was like just a stinger,” he said to the media. “They were just trying to work me, keep the shoulder warm and just keep it feeling good out there.”
Today (Tuesday, Nov. 17) at his weekley press conference, head coach Eric Morris was not definitive, but did paint the picture as undecided at this point.
“Yeah, Drew’s a tough kid and obviously was able to finish the game, and so we'll just continue to monitor how he feels,” Morris said when asked about Mestemaker right off the top. “I mean, he’s as tough as they come, and he’s a competitor at heart and loves this team and loves to compete. He communicates at a high level, so just continue to communicate this week.
“Brody’s (Brodie Vehrs) got a ton of reps throughout the course of the season, being a backup coming in and all those different things,” continued Morris. “But yeah, Drew's gonna be okay.”
If he isn’t then it would be freshman Broderick Vehrs from Basha High School in Gilbert, Ariz. that would ge the start.
Our sources indicate that Mestemaker has been out there at practice but has been a spectator more than a paricipant in the first two days of practice for this week. Running back Caleb Hawkins indicated he thought his quarterback would be ready by Saturday.
The first defining moment will be the first Big 12 issued participation reports that come out Wednesday (Nov. 18) evening. I’m predicting he will be listed as doubtful or questionable. Doubtful is 25 percent chance of playing and questionable is 50 percent chance to play on Saturday. Updates are out on Thursday, Friday, and game day.
Mestemaker has plenty of Big 12 company on the Davey O’Brien lis of semifinalists. There are 13 in all, and five are from the Big 12.
The Big 12 semifinalists include Mestemaker, BYU’s Bear Bachmeier, Utah’s Devon Dampier. Moah Fifita of Arizona, and Houston’s Conner Weigman. Other names on the list include C.J. Carr of Notre Dame, Trinidad Chambliss of Ole Miss, Miami (Fla.) quarterback Darian Mensah, Gio Lopez of Wake Forest, LaNorris Sellers of South Carolina, and Georgia’s Gunner Stockton.
The Davey O’Brien Foundation will announce the three finalists Tuesday, Nov. 24. The 2026 Davey O’Brien Award winner will be unveiled live on ESPN on Friday, Dec. 11, during The Home Depot College Football Awards.