I looked at the AP list. I would put Justin Blackmon on that 1st/2nd team list.
2 Fred Biletnikoff Award (2010, 2011)
2 Paul Warfield Trophy (2010, 2011)
2 Unanimous All-American (2010, 2011)
2 First-team All-Big 12 (2010, 2011)
Big 12 Offensive Player of the Year (2010)
GO POKES!!!
First:
Randy Moss, Marshall, 1997
NCAA I-AA national champion (1996)
Fred Biletnikoff Award (1997)
Paul Warfield Trophy (1997)
Unanimous All-American (1997)
MAC Most Valuable Player (1997)
MAC Offensive Player of the Year (1997)
Larry Fitzgerald, Pittsburgh, 2003
Biletnikoff Award (2003)
Walter Camp Award (2003)
Chic Harley Award (2003)
Paul Warfield Trophy (2003)
Big East Offensive Player of the Year (2003)
Unanimous All-American (2003)
First-team All-Big East (2003)
Pittsburgh Panthers No. 1 retired
Second:
DeVonta Smith, Alabama, 2020
2 CFP national champion (2017, 2020)
CFP National Championship Offensive MVP (2020)
Heisman Trophy (2020)
Walter Camp Award (2020)
Maxwell Award (2020)
Fred Biletnikoff Award (2020)
Paul Hornung Award (2020)
AP College Football Player of the Year (2020)
Sporting News College Football Player of the Year (2020)
SEC Male Athlete of the Year (2021)
SEC Offensive Player of the Year (2020)
Unanimous All-American (2020)
Second-team All-American (2019)
2 First-team All-SEC (2019, 2020)
Desmond Howard, Michigan, 1991
Heisman Trophy (1991)
Maxwell Award (1991)
Walter Camp Award (1991)
UPI Player of the Year (1991)
SN Player of the Year (1991)
Chic Harley Award (1991)
Paul Warfield Trophy (1991)
Unanimous All-American (1991)
Third-team All-American (1990)
Big Ten Male Athlete of the Year (1992)
Big Ten Most Valuable Player (1991)
Big Ten Offensive Player of the Year (1991)
2 First-team All-Big Ten (1990, 1991)
Michigan Wolverines No. 21 retired
GO POKES!!!