Oklahoma State Football

The Top Graded Oklahoma State Cowboys (PFF) Through the First Third of the Season

We watch back each game for review, but don't actually grade. Pro Football Focus grades and here's what they have.
September 28, 2026
618 Views
Discuss
Story Poster
Photo by IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect

STILLWATER – I’ve looked at my Pro Football Focus several times this season, but not as intently as I have in the past when I’ve been working on the Cowboy Radio Network as the sidelines reporter. Today (Sept. 28). I checked out the PFF grades for all of the Oklahoma State games and the totals were exceptional. Sometimes I’m suspect of PFF grades because they grade on base concepts. They don’t have Oklahoma State’s offensive or defensive playbooks. 

IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect
Mestemaker is 95-of-141 passing for 1,271-yards with 11 touchdowns and five interceptions so far.

Starting with the top grades by game, they sure seem to line-up with the results and the performances. Check Drew Mestemaker as an example, he didn’t grade well at all, hardly anybody did at Tulsa, but he has been banging out good grades the last three games and exceptional grades for Murray State and West Virginia. 

On defense, I can appreciate the grades on rush end James Williams and seeing Ethan Wesloski and Tate Romney consistently grading well. End Keviyan Huddleston and safety Vincent Holmes deserved good grades from Saturday in Morgantown.

Top Grading Oklahoma State Players (Offense & Defense) in Each of First Four Games (20+ plays)
Sept. 5 at Tulsa 24-10 loss                                                                                                  

Sept. 12 Oregon 39-31   win                                                                                                                                       

Sept. 19 Murray State 59-0 win                                                                                                                                 Sept. 26 at West Virginia 41-24 win                                                                                      
Offense Defense Offense Defense Offense Defense Offense Defense
Joseph Hanson, RG - 74.9/91 plays James Williams, Rush - 73.4/26 plays Drew Mestemaker, QB - 77.3/87 plays James Williams, Rush - 85.2/24 plays Drew Mestemaker, QB - 93.1/42 plays Mo Horn, CB - 86.5/25 plays Drew Mestemaker, QB - 91.0/70 plays Keviyan Huddleston, End - 82.8/32 plays
Wyatt Young, WR - 72.9/44 plays   Wyatt Young, WR - 73.4/47 plays Jaleel Johnson, End - 82.8/25 plays Justin Bowick, WR - 92.3/41 plays Tate Romney, LB - 83.4/22 plays Wyatt Young, WR - 86.1/51 plays Vincent Holmes, Nickel - 72.5/20 plays
      Ethan Wesloski, LB - 80.3/43 plays Miles Coleman, WR - 81.5/23 plays Ethan Wesloski, LB - 79.7/26 plays Caleb Hawkins, RB - 78.1/58 plays Jaleel Johnson, End - 71.0/46 plays
      Malik Charles, End - 78.7/16 plays Shaun Torgeson, LT - 75.7/49 plays Christian Bodnar, Nickel - 74.0/21 plays Tyler Mercer, OC - 76.7/70 plays Kollin Lewis, CB - 70.6/41 plays
      Tate Romney, LB - 77.6/50 plays Broderick Vehrs, QB - 73.5/49 plays   Terrence Lewis, WR - 73.8/44 plays Saadiq Clements, DT - 70.3/23 plays

The cumulative grades made sense to me. Make sure you take not of snap counts as some of the high grades went to players that played in the second half and likely faced less than stellar or commited competition. 

Cumulative  Winning Grades (70.0 or better) by Oklahoma State Players Through 4 Games
Offensive Player Grade Snap Count Defensive Player Grade Snap Count
Drew Mestemaker, QB 84.4 290 Malik Charles, End 80.1 56
KD Jones, RB 83.7 11 Ethan Wesloski, LB 79.1 207
Wyatt Young, WR 82.6 168 Mo Horn, CB 77.5 141
William Mason, RB 75.3 11 Jaleel Johnson, End 76.9 115
Caleb Hawkins, RB 74.4 204 Jack Puckett, LB 75.8 5
Justin Bowick, WR 74.3 268 Keviyan Huddleston, End 74.5 85
Broderick Vehrs. QB 73.8 32 Saadiq Clements, NT 74.5 92
Joseph Hanson. RG 73.3 192 James Williams, Rush 73.2 112
Ja’Qwon Evans, OL 70.3 25 Isaiah Chisom, LB 72.6 135
      Markeith Williams, BS 71.9 13
      Savion Barthelemy, DT 71.8 7
      Trip White, LB 71.6 17
      Landon Dean, DT 71.5 38
      Vincent Holmes, Nickel 71.1 45
      DJ Jackson Jr, Rush 70.2 72

Finally, I thought to put in total snap counts for the top 10 players on each side of the ball. It is important to note who is getting in the most snaps in games. Also, just as important to note that only one interior defensive lineman (nose or defensive tackle) showed up in the top 10 defensive snaps. 

USA TODAY Network via Reuters Connect
Jerry Lawson with a tackle against Oregon and the defensive tackles combined have 33 tackles combined, nine unassisted, 2.5 tackles-for-loss, and 2.0 sacks.

This is important because in the preseason, I stated that interior defensive line could be an issue for this team. They have countered a lack of overwhelming talent with numbers and constantly keeping fresh legs in on defense. That is a definite and positve way to do it. Fresh legs and body get more push and defeat often tired and weakening offensive linemen. That is a legit way to handle the big men and ability to hold up and even get push upfront.

Top 10 Oklahoma State Players by Snap Counts on Both Sides of the Football
Order Offense Defense
1. Johnny Dickson III, LG - 297 Quinton Hammonds, BS - 239
2. Tyler Mercer, OC - 293 Ethan Wesloski, LB - 207
3. Drew Mestemaker, QB - 290 Christian Bodnar, Nickel - 201
4. Shaun Torgeson, LT - 275 Tate Romney, LB - 196
5. Justin Bowick, WR - 268 LaDainian Fields, CB - 193
6. Ashton Lepo, RT - 249 Mose Phillips III, FS - 179
7. Carson Kolb, TE - 236 Mo Horn, CB - 141
8. Caleb Hawkins, RB - 204 Isaiah Chisom, LB - 135
9. Joseph Hanson, RG - 192 Jerry Lawson, NT - 124
10. Desmond Magiya, OL - 178 Jaleel Johnson, End - 115

 

Discuss
Discussion from...

The Top Graded Oklahoma State Cowboys (PFF) Through the First Third of the Season

465 Views | 0 Replies | Last: 4 hrs ago by Robert Allen
There are not any replies to this post yet.
Refresh
Page 1 of 1
 
×
subscribe Verify your student status
See Subscription Benefits
Trial only available to users who have never subscribed or participated in a previous trial.